The Rise of Synthetic Identities
How Fraudsters Build Fake People to Steal Real Money
Something feels off…like fabric that looks smooth but scratches when you wear it. At first glance, everything checks out. A name, a number, an address. But look closer, and it’s stitched together; real details pulled from different people, woven in with information that was never real to begin with.
These identities are synthetic. Engineered to pass checks, build trust, and behave like any other customer, until the moment they unravel, taking thousands (sometimes millions) with them.
Welcome to synthetic identity fraud, where the person isn’t stolen, they’re manufactured.
What is synthetic identity fraud?
Synthetic identity fraud is a type of financial crime where criminals create a fictitious identity by combining real and fabricated personal information to commit fraud.
Unlike traditional identity theft, where a real person’s identity is hijacked, synthetic identity fraud builds something entirely new: a hybrid persona that looks legitimate on paper but doesn’t correspond to a real person.
It typically works like this:
- A real data point is used (for example, a government ID number, address, or other legitimate identifier)
- Fake details are layered on top (name, date of birth, phone number, email)
- Together, they form a new identity that can pass verification checks
This “combination effect” is what makes synthetic identities so powerful…and so hard to detect.
The building blocks of a fake person
Every synthetic identity is stitched together from two key components:
This might include:
- Government ID numbers
- Driver’s licence details
- Legitimate addresses
These are often sourced through data breaches, leaks, or social engineering.
This includes:
- Made-up names
- Fake dates of birth
- New phone numbers and email addresses
On their own, these wouldn’t pass scrutiny. But combined with real data, they create something that appears credible.
Two ways fraudsters create synthetic identities
Not all fake identities are built the same. There are two common methods:
Manipulated synthetics
Small changes are made to real information, just enough to bypass systems while keeping key identifiers intact.
Manufactured synthetics (“Frankenstein fraud”)
Entirely new identities are created by stitching together real and fake data from multiple sources.
How the scam actually unfolds
Synthetic identity fraud is rarely rushed. It’s patient, strategic, and designed to avoid detection.
Step 1:
A real piece of information is obtained, often belonging to someone unlikely to actively monitor their credit.
Step 2:
A fictional identity is created around it.
Step 3:
Small accounts are opened and carefully managed to build a clean credit history.
Step 4:
Once trust is established, large sums are extracted, loans, credit lines and goods before the identity disappears.
Meet the “people” who don’t exist
These profiles are fictional… but they reflect how real synthetic identities operate.
Polly Ester
- Age: 28
- Occupation: Marketing Coordinator
- Credit Profile: Strong and stable
Polly looks like the ideal customer. Consistent repayments, low-risk behaviour, a growing credit history.
After years of careful build-up, she suddenly takes out multiple high-value loans in quick succession.
Then she vanishes.
Polly was never real…but the financial loss is.
Nyla On
- Age: 34
- Occupation: Freelance Designer
- Online Presence: Convincing
Nyla has a portfolio, social media accounts, even client reviews. Everything appears legitimate.
But her identity is a blend, real identifiers paired with fabricated details.
She gains trust across multiple platforms, then exploits payment systems before disappearing.
Ray On (Nyla’s brother)
- Age: 22
- Occupation: Student
- Credit History: Newly established
Ray starts small, a phone plan, a buy-now-pay-later account.
Over time, limits increase. Trust builds.
Then, in a short window, he maxes out multiple lines of credit simultaneously.
Ray disappears overnight.
Terry Lene
- Age: 39
- Occupation: Operations Manager
- Stability: High
Terry has a long, quiet financial history. No red flags.
That’s exactly what makes the final move so effective.
A large personal loan is approved based on years of “good behaviour.”
It’s never repaid.
Why this crime is so hard to detect
Synthetic identity fraud is uniquely challenging because:
- There’s no single victim reporting it
- The identity behaves like a legitimate customer for months or years
- Fraud only becomes visible at the final stage
By then, the identity has already done its job.
Financial institutions globally are losing billions each year to this type of fraud and the problem is growing.
The role of AI and deepfakes
The rise of AI is making synthetic identities even more convincing.
Fraudsters can now:
- Generate realistic profile photos
- Create believable digital footprints
- Use deepfake audio or video to pass verification checks
The line between real and fake is becoming harder to see, not just for people, but for systems designed to detect fraud.
Who actually pays the price?
Even though the identity is fake, the impact is very real.
- Banks and lenders absorb major financial losses
- Businesses lose goods and revenue
- Individuals whose data was used may face credit complications
- Consumers can experience flow-on effects like stricter lending and higher costs
The unsettling reality
Synthetic identity fraud isn’t about stealing who you are.
It’s about creating someone who never existed, using just enough truth to make the lie believable.
Because in today’s world, you don’t need to be real to be trusted.
You just need to look like you are.
We’ve partnered with BankVic to help keep our community safe from scams and criminal activity while online! Stay up to date with the latest tips and information in one convenient place, empowering you to prevent online crime and outsmart scammers. Together, we can create a safer internet for everyone!
Read articles here.
Been scammed?
Step 1
If you have given any financial details or have already lost money, contact your bank immediately.
It’s also important to change your passwords, monitor your accounts closely, and consider placing a fraud alert on your credit file.
Step 2
Report the scam to police at cyber.gov.au or at your nearest police station.
Additionally, report the scam to Scamwatch and your local authorities to help prevent others from falling victim.
If you think you have been scammed online, IDCARE can help for free! Call 1800 595 160 or visit their website www.idcare.org
Step 3
Getting scammed online does not mean you are not smart. Cybercrime keeps changing, so anyone can be a target. Do not be embarrassed or hard on yourself! Learn about new scams and take steps to stay safe instead.
If you need support after falling victim to a scam talk to friends and family or contact:
Lifeline: 13 11 14
Beyond Blue: 1300 22 4636
Step 4
If you have given any financial details or have already lost money, contact your bank immediately.aFinally, talk about different types of emerging scams and if you have been scammed share your experience with family and friends so they can better recognise the signs of scams.
Smart Scam Guide
Download a comprehensive guide to spotting scams. Download to learn about the most common scams and what to do if you have fallen victim to one.